With the Outer Banks creators stating they’re looking to wrap up all stories in season 5, the show gets the perfect opportunity to address its biggest John B mystery. The Netflix hit has followed the Pogues on four treasure hunts and through many parental betrayals and revelations. John B’s relationship with his father made him the leading Pogue of past seasons, giving him a personal stake in the gold from the Royal Merchant and El Dorado. Notably, the Outer Banks season 4 ending benched the character, removing him from the final battle for the Blue Crown.

While the focus on JJ’s ancestry was well received, John B’s smaller role provoked a wave of mixed reviews for Outer Banks season 4 part 1. Though it’s nice that the Pogue got a chance to catch his breath, his story is far from over. The show’s heavy focus on parents demands it answers the popular mystery surrounding John B’s mother, especially since the creators promise that season 5 will offer closure for all the Outer Banks character’s parents (via Deadline). The return of John B’s mother would bring the show full circle and honor his importance as the series’ anchor.

Outer Banks Season 5 Needs To Finally Reveal What Happened To John B’s Mother

John B’s Mother Is Outer Banks’ Biggest Enigma

 Season 1 of Outer Banks establishes that John B’s mother abandoned him when he was three and could be in Colorado. That explanation has been insufficient to appease the strong interest in the missing character, especially since the secrecy surrounding the rest of Pogues’ parents has often proved intentional. In season 3, John B accuses his father of using him and his mother to drive his lifelong treasure hunt. Big John gives no answer, feeding the mystery behind his failed marriage. Since John B was very little when his mom “split,” his father could have easily lied about it.

Season 5 of Outer Banks is currently being written and aims to start production in spring 2025.

A popular season 3 theory on John B’s mother made a solid case for Carla Limbrey. Although the character has since disappeared from the show, it wouldn’t be shocking to see her return if she discovers the Pogues got hold of a supposed wish-granting object like the Blue Crown. Though there are plenty of reasons why Limbrey is not related to John B, previous seasons could have debunked the big mystery by offering the littlest fact regarding his mother’s actual location and status. Instead, she has become the show’s biggest enigma.

JJ’s Outer Banks Season 4 Story Opened The Door To Solving The Pogues’ Mother Mysteries

Outer Banks Creators Hint Sarah and John B’s Mothers Are Essential To Season 5 Arc

 

For all the show’s heavy focus on fathers, it has always been odd that the Pogues’ mothers are a constant and unaddressed mystery. Though the lack of maternal presence became an accepted status quo, season 4 subverted expectations by solving the mystery behind JJ’s real mother in Outer Banks. The new season’s use of flashbacks to show Larissa Genrette’s story introduced the possibility to finally address the fates of Sarah and John B’s mothers. Whether alive or dead, the show could show a glimpse into what happened to them and how it informs the characters’ concluding arc.

In recent interviews, the Outer Banks creators offered vague responses when asked about a possible “mom’s season 5 arc.” (via Deadline) However, they confirmed that they intend to try “to pull in all those parental relationships and have it reflect on [the characters] being parents.” (via Tudum) Notably, the Outer Banks season 4 part 2 endingbegins to uncover the mystery behind Sarah’s mother, as Rafe using her ring to propose to Sofia suggests she is dead. Accordingly, creator Jonas Pate briefly commented that Sarah’s pregnancy arc is linked to the “big hole” her mother’s absence left.

For his part, John B’s approaching father role has already started getting him to reflect on Big John’s troubling decisions to put treasure over family. As Outer Banks’ final hunt stems from honoring JJ, the character’s last wishes pave the way for familial reconciliation. However, season 5 is sure to feature plenty of conflict before that. Having John B’s mother, or her story, play a key role in the final quest aligns perfectly with the show’s tradition of presenting big parental revelations. Additionally, it would be the perfect way to return John B to the driving seat one last time.