Country superstar Carrie Underwood wasn’t American Idol’s first pick to replace Katy Perry, but a budget-friendly choice, sources claimed.

The show’s top contender was Miley Cyrus, but her steep salary demands became a dealbreaker.

A show source alleged to Radar: “Idol ratings have slid the past few years, so they were looking for a more affordable option.”

According to a network insider: “It’s well known internally Miley Cyrus was the network and the producers’ first choice to replace Katy, but topping Katy’s already high salary was never on the table.”

In the end, Underwood, 41, agreed to join for $12 million, the same as fellow judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan.

Celebrity Sightings In New York City – September 25, 2024© Getty

Click here to follow Daily Express US on Google News to stay up to date with all the latest US, showbiz, and sports news.

“Carrie really wanted to get on board with Idol,” said a source.

“Money wasn’t a big motivation for her; it was more getting off the road from touring and being able to spend more time with her family.”

Idol© Getty

Meanwhile, producers still wonder what might have been if they’d secured Miley, 31.

The insider added: “Miley would have brought a lot of Katy-like sass to American Idol. Carrie is more reserved and will be nicer to the contestants.”

“But Idol still got the big name they sought-and at a price they could swallow,” they finished.

The all-new American Idol with Carrie Underwood will kick off in spring 2025.

Get all the latest news, entertainment, sport and lifestyle updates from our dedicated American team.