If you’ve been on Netflix recently, you’ve probably noticed there’s a new #1 show in the US. Nobody Wants This is a brand-new romantic comedy series that has everyone talking.
Netflix
With their differing outlooks on life, coupled with modern dating obstacles and some well-meaning but sabotaging family members, Joanne and Noah might be the answer the other person was searching for.
Netflix
Erin Foster / Instagram / Via instagram.com
Erin Foster / Instagram / Via instagram.com
Speaking about knowing he wanted to marry a Jewish woman, Simon told the LA Times, “I really respect my parents and know the adversity they went through because they were Jewish. I wouldn’t want to disappoint them.”
Jason Laveris / FilmMagic / Getty Images
Her father has been married five times, with his second wife being Erin’s mom.
David has been married to Katharine McPhee, who is almost two years younger than Erin, since 2019.
In an interview with Vulture, Erin said, “To me, normal is exotic.”
Charley Gallay / Getty Images for Netflix
Simon’s parents emigrated from the former Soviet Union to the US in 1979.
Netflix
Erin said when she told the sunflower story in the Nobody Wants This writers’ room, “the men were baffled, but the women immediately got it.” She added, “That made me feel like it was a good story to tell.”
Netflix
Simon recalled in the same Vulture interview, “I personally don’t remember the sunflowers being that big. But I do remember driving home and thinking, It’s not about the flowers.”
Erin Foster / Instagram / Via instagram.com
While appearing on Erin and her sister Sara Foster’s podcast, The World’s First Podcast, in 2021, Simon said, “For someone to do that for you…[it] is the biggest thing you could ever do. I’ll always be grateful for Erin.”
Also sharing their love story on her podcast, Erin added, “They say being a Jewish couple is not about what you learn in class. It’s about the drive home together and what you talk about. Being a Jewish couple is about how you implement it into your lives.”
Erin Foster / Instagram / Via instagram.com
She told Vulture about when she first went to synagogue with Simon’s family for a Rosh Hashanah service, and afterward, she admitted that she “wasn’t that moved.” She said, “I knew immediately I’d made a mistake,” and they fought.
Erin Foster / Instagram / Via instagram.com
She continued, saying, “But in a TV show, you have to have conflict. It’s important that I had Noah’s parents in the show be immigrants because immigrant culture is very different than American Jewish culture.”
Erin Foster / Instagram / Via instagram.com
Erin documented the whole thing on her Instagram story at the time, with Erin captioning a photo of Simon down on one knee with, “I was in shock.”
Erin Foster / Instagram / Via instagram.com
Speaking about their wedding to People, Erin said, “I think as women, your whole life is built around your wedding day, and you really should focus much more on the marriage that’s going to come after it. So, Simon and I have been paying attention to the kind of relationship that we have and the marriage we’re gonna have, and that’s so much more important than a wedding.”
Netflix
In fact, Erin was so worried that she hoped the pilot and offer for Nobody Wants This, which was originally sold to Fox and titled something else, would disappear, but they didn’t.
With the help of one of the executive producers, Steve Levitan, who created Modern Family, Erin and Simon began to feel more comfortable with using their story for a TV show when Erin changed Noah to be less like Simon IRL, namely making Noah a rabbi.
Netflix
Simon also told the LA Times, “Also, this is what Erin’s supposed to be doing. She’s a writer, and she’s incredible at it. I was sitting here the other day watching an episode and thinking, ‘I wish I was as good as this character.'”
Recently, Erin also responded to criticism from some in the Jewish community about the depiction of Jewish women in Nobody Wants This. She told the LA Times, “I think we need positive Jewish stories right now. I think it’s interesting when people focus on, ‘Oh, this is a stereotype of Jewish people,’ when you have a rabbi as the lead. A hot, cool, young rabbi who smokes weed. That’s the antithesis of how people view a Jewish rabbi, right?”
Since she didn’t grow up Jewish, Erin also made sure the writers’ room was filled with colleagues who were born Jewish.
Netflix
She continued, saying, “This is my worldview. No one’s going to be able to change it. These are my habits. They are what they are. And then you meet someone who totally turns that upside down, who makes you want to be a better version of yourself, and who makes you question all the things that you thought were true.”
Erin Foster / Instagram / Via instagram.com
In an Instagram post about giving birth at home, Erin wrote, “We feel so lucky and grateful. No matter how hard the journey is, once you get to where you were aiming for, none of it matters.”
Erin Foster / Instagram / Via instagram.com
She told the LA Times, “I didn’t think it was possible, and I had gotten kind of OK with that. And now I have to stop myself from going over and sitting in his lap. I’m obsessed with Simon; he’s my muse. And this show is like a love letter to him.”