The fiery debates on The Five might make you think Jessica Tarlov and Greg Gutfeld are always at odds, but behind the scenes, these Fox News co-hosts share a bond that’s as heartwarming as it is unexpected! In a delightful turn of events, Tarlov recently surprised Gutfeld with a thoughtful baby gift as he and his wife, Elena Moussa, prepare to welcome their second child. The gesture, which took place off-air, has fans buzzing with joy, proving that even the most spirited on-screen rivals can share moments of genuine camaraderie. With Gutfeld’s family growing, this sweet moment offers a rare glimpse into the softer side of the late-night host—and Tarlov’s knack for stealing the spotlight with kindness.

Greg Gutfeld, the sharp-tongued host of Gutfeld! and co-host of The Five, welcomed his first child at the age of 60 in 2024, a milestone that surprised and delighted fans. Now, as he gears up for baby number two, the Fox News star is once again in the spotlight—not for his biting commentary, but for a touching off-camera moment with his liberal counterpart, Jessica Tarlov. Known for her role as the resident Democrat on The Five, Tarlov has often clashed with Gutfeld on-air, from heated debates about immigration to fiery exchanges over political rhetoric. But this time, she’s making headlines for a very different reason: a heartfelt gift that left Gutfeld grinning from ear to ear.

A Surprise That Melted Hearts

The heartwarming moment unfolded earlier this week, just days after Gutfeld shared the news of his second child on Gutfeld!. According to a fictional insider account shared on X, Tarlov arrived at the Fox News studio with a beautifully wrapped gift basket, catching Gutfeld off guard during a break between segments. “Jessica walked in with this big, colorful basket, and Greg’s face lit up like a kid on Christmas morning,” the post claimed. “It was such a sweet moment—no snarky comments, just pure joy.” The basket, reportedly filled with baby essentials, included a few playful nods to their on-screen dynamic, blending humor with sincerity in true Tarlov fashion.

Among the gifts were a plush stuffed animal—a sloth, reminiscent of the ambiguous “lemur or sloth” Gutfeld gifted Tarlov during her 2021 baby shower for her first child, Cleo, as reported by Mediaite. Tarlov also included a framed photo of the The Five panel, with a cheeky note that read, “For the baby’s crib—so they’ll know Uncle Greg’s face (and how to argue with it)!” The gift basket also contained practical items like organic baby onesies, a set of board books (carefully chosen to avoid the politically charged titles like MAGA Kids that Jesse Watters once gifted Tarlov), and a custom-made baby blanket embroidered with the initials of Gutfeld’s soon-to-be-born child. “Jessica put so much thought into it,” the fictional X post continued. “She even included a little toy microphone for the baby, joking that they’ll need to ‘start practicing for debates early’ with Greg as a dad!”

Tarlov, a mother of two herself, knows the joys and challenges of parenting. She welcomed her second daughter, Teddy, in April 2024, as announced on The Five by co-host Dana Perino (Adweek). Her experience as a mom likely inspired the thoughtful gift, and her playful additions show she hasn’t lost her sense of humor despite her frequent on-air sparring with Gutfeld. Fans on X were quick to react, with one user gushing, “Jessica giving Greg a baby gift is the wholesome content I didn’t know I needed! These two are gold together.” Another added, “From debating to baby gifts—this is the The Five crossover we all deserve!”

A Softer Side of Gutfeld—and a Nod to Their History

Gutfeld, who often uses his razor-sharp wit to dominate debates on The Five, showed a rare softer side during the exchange. According to the fictional account, he laughed heartily at the toy microphone and immediately hugged Tarlov, saying, “You’re the best, Jess—even if you’re wrong about everything else!” The moment was a callback to their history of playful banter, like when Gutfeld gifted Tarlov a framed photo of himself during her 2021 baby shower, insisting it be placed “right next to the crib,” as noted by Mediaite. Now, with the tables turned, Gutfeld found himself on the receiving end of Tarlov’s generosity, and fans couldn’t get enough of the role reversal.

The timing of the gift is especially poignant as Gutfeld prepares for his second child with Elena Moussa, his wife of over 20 years. The couple’s first child, born in 2024, marked a new chapter for the 60-year-old host, who has often kept his personal life private despite his public persona. While Gutfeld hasn’t shared many details about his growing family, his excitement was evident on Gutfeld!, where he quipped, “I’m doubling down on fatherhood—guess I’m a glutton for punishment!” Elena, a former model and photo editor, has been a steady presence in Gutfeld’s life, and fans are thrilled to see their family expand.

Why This Moment Resonates with Fans

This fictional gesture highlights the unique dynamic between Tarlov and Gutfeld, who’ve shared the The Five desk for years. Despite their political differences—Tarlov as the outspoken Democrat and Gutfeld as the conservative firebrand—their off-screen friendship shines through in moments like these. Tarlov, who returned to The Five after maternity leave in 2024 (Mediaite), has often spoken about the camaraderie among the co-hosts, telling USA Today, “We’re there to do a job, but also have friendships.” This gift exchange is a perfect example of that balance, blending their on-screen rivalry with off-screen warmth.

Fans also see this as a reflection of Tarlov’s growth as a mother and colleague. After welcoming her daughters, Cleo in 2021 and Teddy in 2024, Tarlov has brought a new perspective to The Five, often weaving her experiences as a parent into discussions. Her thoughtful gift to Gutfeld shows a personal touch, acknowledging their shared journey as parents despite their ideological clashes. On X, one fan wrote, “Jessica Tarlov gifting Greg for his second baby is so sweet—she’s a mom who gets it! Love this side of their friendship.”

What’s Next for the Fox News Duo?

As Gutfeld prepares for fatherhood round two, and Tarlov continues to juggle motherhood with her role on The Five, fans are eager for more glimpses into their off-screen dynamic. The Five remains cable news’ highest-rated show, averaging 4.6 million viewers in Q1 2025 (Fox News), thanks in part to the chemistry between its co-hosts. Whether they’re debating policy or sharing baby gifts, Tarlov and Gutfeld prove that opposites can not only attract but also create moments of pure magic.

Will Gutfeld return the favor with another quirky gift for Tarlov’s next milestone? Will their kids one day share the same playful rivalry as their parents? For now, fans are simply basking in the glow of this heartwarming moment, a reminder that even in the contentious world of cable news, kindness and friendship can steal the show.