The crucial character was subtly different in Tolkein’s source material
The second season of The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power is drawing to a close, but how does Celebrimbor’s fate in the show differ from Tolkein’s original story?
The first seven episodes of the second season of the show are streaming on Amazon Prime Video now, with the closing instalment to be released onto the streamer on October 3.Created by J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay, the prequel series is set thousands of years before J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord Of The Rings trilogy and depicts the rise of Sauron in Middle-earth’s Second Age.
The show’s cast is led by Morfydd Clark as Galadriel, alongside Lenny Henry, Ciarán Hinds and Rory Kinnear, with Jack Lowden joining as a young Sauron.
The show initially proved divisive among critics so far, and its audience has reportedly halved in size as it has gone on, but some fans hailed the recent seventh episode as “one of the best TV episodes of the year”.
In a four-star review of this season, NME wrote: “The action comes to a head in an epic battle told across two episodes, balanced against some excellent character work (and surprising deaths). Those who complained that nothing happened in House Of The Dragon’s sophomore effort will thrill at how The Rings Of Power refuses to slump.”
“Indeed, the second season improves on the first, sharpening its narrative and taking assured footsteps forward as the writers continues to tell this expansive tale. Let’s just hope the series doesn’t make like the hobbits and end up going in circles.”
What happens to Celebrimbor in The Silmarillion – and how does it differ from The Rings Of Power?
The Rings Of Power is based largely on Tolkein’s appendices from The Lord Of The Rings, which include detailed histories, timelines and genealogies that the writer used to establish the foundation for much of the lore of Middle Earth, especially events from the Second Age.
In Amazon’s deal to secure the rights for the show, they obtained the rights to The Lord Of The Rings and its appendices, but not those of The Silmarillion, a collection of epic stories that Tolkein wrote about Middle Earth lore that were published in 1977, after his death.
In The Silmarillion, Celebrimbor is a key figure. An Elven smith of great skill, he is the grandson of Feanor, and he is deceived by Sauron, disguised as Annatar, into forging the Rings of Power. Celebrimbor creates the three Elven Rings, while Sauron forges the One Ring in Mordor, granting him power over the other rings.
Celebrimbor realises Sauron’s deceit and hides the Elven Rings from him, causing the Eregion War that sees Celebrimbor being captured. Sauron tortures Celebrimbor to reveal the location of the Elven Rings, but he refuses, and Sauron ultimately kills him.
In The Rings Of Power, events play out slightly differently, in that Celebrimbor is depicted as a significantly older figure who has become a master, but who feels he has yet to achieve his legacy. He is more heavily influenced by ‘Halbrand’, the name for Sauron’s cover in the show in place of ‘Annatar’, in the creation of the rings, in particular the three Elven Rings. Celebrimbor created those on his own, in secret, in the source material, but in Amazon’s version, Sauron is seen to exert more influence.
In the seventh episode of The Rings Of Power, Sauron reveals his disguise to Celebrimbor, who then tries to warm his soldiers, but Sauron has already convinced them that Celebrimbor is mentally unwell. Celebrimbor is imprisoned and attempts to escape with the nine rings, only to be captured by his soldiers.
Galadriel finds them and convinces the soldiers to set him free by convincing them that he has been telling the truth all along. He gives Galadriel the nine rings and attempts to delay Sauron.
With one episode remaining, it is still unclear exactly how differently events will play out in the show, compared with The Silmarillion.
News
The Rings Of Power just re-enacted Boromir’s death scene and yes a lot of people are sitting here crying right now
The Rings of Power has recreated Boromir’s death scene, and the emotion I felt proved how impactful it is decades later. Much of The Rings of Power season 2 has focused on Sauron’s grand Lord of the Rings plan. In The Rings of Power season 2, episode 7,…
The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power returns with eight epic episodes of Season 2
Welcome back to Middle-earth. IF THE SECOND season of House of the Dragon left you with a taste for fantasy epic and wanting more, you’ve come to the right place and are living in the right timeline. Not even a month after HBO…
Amazon’s The Lord of the Rings prequel gives some much-needed complexity to Sauron
Amazon’s The Lord of the Rings prequel gives some much-needed complexity to Sauron. Listing the things wrong with The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power’s second season feels like a job in itself. Between its ponderous pacing, its unwieldy storylines, and its…
The Rings of Power seriously just gave us one of the best TV episodes of 2024
Unlike many of you, I actually made it all the way to the end of the first season of Prime Video’s Lord of the Rings prequel series — which is why, once Season 2 of The Rings of Power finally arrived on Prime, I felt invested…
Lord of the Rings fans were too quick to condemn The Rings of Power after witnessing these things
It’s no secret that Prime Video’s The Rings of Power has been controversial among Lord of the Rings fans. From the very beginning, longtime lovers of Middle-earth have been wary about the new series, which aims to tell a more complete story about the…
Finally this is the Gil-galad I wanted from The Rings Of Power 2 years ago – UNBELIEVABLE!
I have been disappointed with how The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power portrayed High King Gil-galad, but season 2, episode 7, completely turned this around. While the Prime Video series has been more or less faithful to Tolkien’s works…
End of content
No more pages to load