FX’s Shogun has garnered so much popularity that talks are being held about bringing the miniseries back for another season, but there are eight big reasons that Shogun season 2 would be a bad idea. Shogun is based on James Clavell’s 1975 novel of the same name, which was also adapted into a miniseries in 1980. Shogun‘s excellent cast and masterful production has helped it eclipse the 1980 version, launching Clavell’s story back into the public eye in stunning fashion.

By the end of Shogun, it’s natural for fans to immediately want another installment. The miniseries is so engrossing and addictive that it’s nearly impossible not to reach the end and be desperate for another season to materialize. However, despite the brilliance of Shogun, returning for a sequel season would be a huge risk. Ultimately, there are eight major reasons that bringing Shogun back for a second season would be a mistake for FX and Hulu.

Shogun Season 1 Exhausted The Source Material

Shogun Is Based On James Clavell’s 1975 Novel Of The Same Name

The most obvious reason that Shogun season 2 shouldn’t happen is that season 1 covered the entirety of the 1975 novel it’s based on, leaving it without an obvious way to move the story forward. A major part of Shogun‘s incredible success comes from the incredibly engaging narrative provided by Clavell’s novel, which means a potential Shogun season 2 would be taking a huge risk by trying to come up with a story worthy of succeeding the original.

While it’s clear that Shogun‘s writing team is extremely talented, it would be difficult to craft a worthy season 2 without the historical expertise of someone like Clavell. The brilliance of the narrative lies in its ability to reinterpret history in a way that is largely speculative, but not at all misleading. That’s a fine line to walk, and without years of studying the history and culture of the people one hopes to depict, it’s all but impossible to do it as well as Clavell. It’s not impossible to write a worthy Shogun sequel, but it would be incredibly difficult.

Shogun’s Story Was Never Meant To Span Multiple Seasons

Shogun’s Story Is Perfect As A Miniseries

Shogun‘s complex and somewhat ambiguous storytelling is perfect for a miniseries, but the limited nature of the story was never meant to span more than one season. With that in mind, Shogun season 2 would almost definitely drop a notch in terms of its storytelling, and it could overexplain the little gray areas and unanswered questions that made season 1’s finale so good. Further, the history Shogun is based on becomes far less intriguing after the establishment of the Edo shogunate.

History aside, Shogun‘s ending also leaves the characters in what feels like the right place to end their stories. All the character arcs in Shogun are written specifically to last for one season, and because they were all done so well, none of them feel like they have a natural progression that could provide a basis for Shogun season 2. In fact, everything about Shogun was written and produced to last for one season, so trying to stretch the narrative out for another installment could significantly dilute season 1’s brilliance.

Toranaga’s Rule Wouldn’t Be As Entertaining As His Rise

Toranaga Becomes Shogun After Season 1’s Conclusion

He would undoubtedly be just as magnetic on-screen, but the story of his administrative reforms and consolidation of power are decidedly less eventful than his rise to power.

At the end of Shogun season 1, Toranaga reveals his plan to Yabushige, describing the inevitability of his triumph over Ichido and his installment as shogun. This moment reveals the depth of Toranaga’s strategies and represents the peak of his story, meaning there might not be much for his character to offer in a potential season 2. He would undoubtedly be just as magnetic on-screen, but the story of his administrative reforms and consolidation of power are decidedly less eventful than his rise to power.

That’s not to say that Tokugawa Ieyasu — the historical figure Toranaga is based on — didn’t have any challenges to deal with after becoming shogun, but nothing he dealt with was nearly as dramatic as his rise to power. Outside of pacifying a few rebellious clans, most of his reign was spent setting up the dynasty that would rule Japan until midway through the 19th century, so Shogun would likely have to lean into fiction to make Toranaga’s story work in season 2, potentially damaging the quality of the narrative.

Too Many Of Shogun’s Best Characters Are Dead

Lady Mariko And Yabushige’s Deaths Make Season 2 More Difficult

One of the things that makes Shogun so good is its ruthless refusal to give even its best characters plot armor, but unfortunately, that makes it more difficult to return for a second season. Lady Mariko and Yabushige are two of Shogun‘s most complex and intriguing characters, so their deaths in season 1 would be felt keenly if the series were to return. Shogun season 2 would also be missing its striking antagonist, Lord Ichido, whose devious schemes were the perfect distraction for Toranaga’s strategies.

Although Shogun‘s creative team could almost certainly come up with some engaging new characters, it would be nearly impossible to replicate what each of these characters meant to Toranaga. Ichido is used to disguise Toranaga’s ruthless ambition, Lady Mariko represents the sacrifices he is willing to make, and Yabushige’s teetering foreshadows Toranaga’s ability to play both sides of the field. While Shogun season 2 could come up with some intriguing characters, it’s unlikely they would complement each other so perfectly.

Shogun Season 2 Could Spoil Season 1’s Perfect Ending

Shogun’s Finale Strikes A Perfect Balance Between Clarity And Ambiguity

Shogun‘s finale wrapped the show up in a perfect way, making it a huge risk to renew the show for a second season. The final episode finds the perfect balance between answering the audience’s questions and leaving things open to interpretation. This is an incredibly difficult balance to find at the end of a TV series, and returning for a second season would almost certainly upset that balance. The show would have to answer questions about Blackthorne, Toranaga, and others that are better left to the imagination.

Blackthorne’s future is a particularly good example of this because it leaves almost everything up in the air, yet doesn’t feel incomplete in any way. Blackthorne is last seen hauling the wreckage of his ship out of the sea, and for the first time in the entire series, he seems to be at peace. Despite losing Mariko and the boat that could’ve taken him home, he finally finds a sense of purpose and belonging that allows him to move forward. Ultimately, returning for a second season isn’t worth spoiling perfect endings like Blackthorne’s.

Shogun Season 1 Set The Bar Impossibly High

Shogun Has Been Lauded As One Of The Best Miniseries Of The Decade

Another issue a potential Shogun season 2 would face is that it would be incredibly difficult to live up to the standard of the first season, which makes it harder to satisfy fans expecting the same level of quality. Shogun season 2 could end up being one of the best shows of the year and still fall well short of what it produced in the first season. Shogun‘s creatives are evidently capable of creating something spectacular, but it’s difficult to catch lightning in a bottle more than once.

Further, it would be difficult to replicate the stakes of Shogun‘s first season without a historical event of similar importance, and there are none that involve the same figures represented in the show. The tension and pulse-pounding suspense are what makes Shogun so entertaining, and without similar stakes to build that tension around, it’s hard to imagine the second season matching the quality of the first. With that in mind, Shogun season 2 would be likely to disappoint fans no matter how good it is.

Shogun’s Legacy As An Outstanding Miniseries Is Enough

Shogun Season 2 Could Tarnish Its Sparkling Reputation

Shogun has garnered a reputation as one of the best miniseries in decades, which gives it another reason not to move forward with a second season. Its legacy as an outstanding miniseries is already firmly established, but if the show were to move into a full series, it would be considered in a different light. Shogun could go from one of the best miniseries ever made to that one show that had an excellent first season before falling off the map.

Of course, if Shogun were to return and continue the brilliance of season 1, then it would have an opportunity to expand its legacy beyond miniseries.

Of course, if Shogun were to return and continue the brilliance of season 1, then it would have an opportunity to expand its legacy beyond miniseries. However, considering how difficult it would be to replicate the show’s initial success, the more likely outcome is that a sequel season would damage Shogun‘s legacy. That said, it might be better for FX and Shogun to be content with having produced such a fantastic miniseries and move on to the next project.

Japan Entered A Time Of Relative Peace After Sekigahara

The Battle Of Sekigahara Led To The Start Of The Edo Shogunate

As previously mentioned, one of the big issues with returning for Shogun season 2 is that the events depicted in season 1 were the start of a new era of unification in Japan, which was far more peaceful and progressive than the century before. After the establishment of the Edo shogunate, or Tokugawa shogunate as it’s also referred to, the country underwent a series of economic and governmental reforms that are intriguing to a scholar, but less so to the wide audience Shogun wants to appeal to.

This is not to say that the Edo period was a time of complete peace and prosperity — schemes and skirmishes can always be found in medieval society — but nothing in the immediate aftermath of the events depicted in Shogun could compare to the momentous occurrences seen in the miniseries. Of course, Shogun is historical fiction and could easily make up a new story, but that would dampen the show’s appeal to history-oriented fans, who likely make up a large portion of its audience.